Maid to Match, by Deeanne Gist


My mum handed me Maid to Match (Bethany House Publishers, 2010) back in early February, right around the time I started this blog. I was working on other darker things at the time, so the fluffy romance got pushed to the back burner. I know romance novels (and their authors) often get a lot of grief for being what they are, but I’m firmly rooted in the camp that they have their place and purpose and are just as important as anything you’d find on the literary fiction shelf. For me, TRNs (trashy romance novels) are equivalent to dessert or a piece of Vosges Haut-Chocolate in the middle of a stressful work day. Sometimes I like picking up a book with strong female leads and sexy men and knowing that everything is going to turn out alright! (Though I have to amend right off the bat that Gist and Bethany House take the T out of the TRN!)

After finishing a dark, disturbing young adult novel, Maid to Match was exactly what I needed. Set in stunning North Carolina, on the Biltmore Estate in 1898, the story begins with the introduction of Tillie Reese, our immediately likable heroine. Tillie, the head parlormaid, is on the brink of becoming a lady’s maid to the Mrs. Vanderbilt. She craves the elite position and everything that goes with it; books, baths, fashionable dresses, travel and better pay (“so she could help her family and others in the community who were in need”). Tillie’s big heart and level head make her a shoe-in for the position, not to mention that Tillie’s over-bearing mama has been grooming Tillie for the position all her life.

Enter Mack Danvers, the rugged mountain man with a heart of gold. His handsome countenance, plus the fact that his twin is currently a Vanderbilt-employed footman, kick him right onto the fast track of servitude. After all, anyone in the upper echelon of turn-of-the-century society can employ a handsome footman, but think of the prestige that would come with employing a matching set.


The heavy responsibility of de-mountain-manning Mack somehow falls on sweet Tilly and of course, sparks (squeaky clean sparks) fly. Tillie does her best to avoid Mack’s advances because one does not engage in inter-service romance, especially if she wants to be come lady’s maid. However, the more time our hero and heroine are forced to spend together, the more Tillie learns about the real reason Mack has emerged from his mountain home and the more her heart softens toward him.

What I enjoyed the most about this book was that it introduced me to a setting and time in American history that, in retrospect, seems to be overlooked in the romance genre in general. Gist’s well-researched storyline waltzes the reader through the lush Biltmore Estate with its modern swimming pool and bowling alley, shady orphanages run by dodgy characters, and the beautiful Carolina mountains and their clans. Gist outlines in her author’s note just what was historically accurate and what she stretched for the sake of the story, which I thought was pretty cool.

Let’s talk about S-E-X for a sec. Bethany House is a publisher of Christian fiction and romance, and when I started Maid to Match, I wasn’t aware of the fact. Being much more accustomed to the bodice-rippers of Stephanie Laurens and others like her, I felt a little, well, frustrated that all that sexual tension between Tillie and Mack never had an outlet, or rather, that the outlet was merely alluded to. It makes more sense upon my discovery that the book came from a Christian publisher, but was odd and, er, anti-climactic at the time.

Bottom line: If you are looking for a light-hearted romance with a sweet, likable heroine and some fascinating American history lore, Maid to Match is a good one to pick up. Just be aware that this is no titillating TRN!


2 responses to “Maid to Match, by Deeanne Gist

  • house painting naperville

    I like the helpful info you provide in your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here regularly. I am quite sure I will learn plenty of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  • Cadi

    I read ‘Maid to Match’ and it was awful! Never in my life have I been more disgusted by a Christian romance novel.
    My mom bought me ‘Courting Troubles’ and I thought it looked good from the front and back covers. But I didn’t even make it halfway through that book before I threw it in the dumpster….literally. Any time I pick up a book by Deeanne Gist, it’s because I think the cover looks amazing and interesting. I was contemplating reading ‘Love on the Line’ because the cover captures your attention. But ‘Maid to Match’ made my decision for me: it will only leave me disappointed.
    The main problem I had with this book was the touchy-feelyness of the characters. It was all they could do to NOT be kissing or heavy petting each other and mostly this came from Mack’s side, which I found very disrespectful. Not to mention, it totally clashes with who the character is claiming to be. He claims he wants to protect women and respect them and, to me, forcing himself on the girl was disgusting. I like a little romance but (and call me stuck up) I think romance should be as pure and undefined as it can be. What kind of respectful, God-fearing man would jump clear over a table just to corner a woman who obviously did not want his advances???
    And, call me crazy, but to me, the kiss is almost a sacred part of the story. In this book, it feels almost like a kiss isn’t special…it’s just another way to get your hands on the opposite sex’s body! Sorry, but in a Christian romance, God is supposed to be the lesson. You shouldn’t have to throw Him in there at the last second just so you can call it ‘Christian’. If you like Lynn Austin, Lauraine Snelling, Catherine Palmer, Judith Miller, or Tracie Peterson, this is not your kind of story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: